Apparently the shark was caught on the evening of November 20, 2013. The Haiti Observer believes that the two fishermen were most likely fishing in a "bya fouye" which is a very small, hand crafted boat.
After it was brought to shore, a large crowd gathered to have a look. Eventually a crane (3:30 mark) was used to place the animal on a flatbed truck at which point we assume it was taken to be butchered.
One exchange quite succinctly summed up the thoughts on both camps. Jime49 posted a comment on Youtube stating, "They shouldn't killed the shark .That's animal cruelty to nature?" To which Peter Moore replied, "animal cruelty!not in haiti.dinner."
Video was posted by Palecho Breaking News Haiti and is just over six minutes in length.